Shortening Vs Butter In Biscuits

Okay, let's talk biscuits. The kind you slam on the counter next to gravy. Not the fancy British ones with clotted cream. The real deal. And there's one debate that rages in kitchens everywhere: should you use shortening or butter?

Sounds boring, right? Wrong. This is like asking someone if they're a cat person or a dog person. People have feelings about this. Strong feelings.

What Even Is Shortening?

First things first. Shortening is basically fat that's been stripped of all its water. It's like butter's emotionless cousin who went to engineering school instead of art school.

The name is helpful. It "shortens" gluten strands in dough, which means tender biscuits. That's it. That's the whole gig. Solid white fat with zero drama.

And here's a quirky fact: the word "shortening" dates back to centuries ago. Bakers figured out that adding fat made bread and biscuits crumbly and soft. They weren't geniuses with lab coats. Just hungry people with good instincts.

What About Butter?

Butter is the classic choice. It gives biscuits that rich, golden, fancy-pants flavor that makes people close their eyes and whisper "wow." Butter = flavor. Full stop.

Shortening And Butter Biscuits

But butter has a big weakness. It melts fast. If your warm room turns your butter into a puddle, your biscuits can go flat. You end up with something closer to a pancake than a biscuit.

Also, butter contains about 16 to 18 percent water. That water turns to steam when baking, which actually helps creating those beautiful flaky layers. Gotta love a little chaos in the process.

The Great Biscuit Showdown

Shortening creates the tallest, fluffiest biscuits. Every single time. It doesn't care about room temperature. It doesn't melt. It basically just sits there being perfectly consistent and dependable.

Butter creates the most delicious biscuits. The flavor is unmatched. Nothing in your kitchen smells better than butter biscuits in the oven. Your whole house becomes a bakery.

The Science of Biscuits : 14 Steps (with Pictures) - Instructables

So the big question is: do you want height or do you want flavor? It's the biscuit equivalent of choosing between a stylish outfit or something ridiculously comfortable.

The Secret Third Option

Plot twist! Some bakers use both. Yes, both. Shortening for structure, butter for taste. It sounds like cheating. It's totally legal though. And honestly? It's genius.

Using both gives you the best of both worlds. The biscuits rise tall, stay flaky, AND have that unmistakable buttery punch. Kitchen science at its finest.

Food scientists have even weighed in, which is hilarious. One shortening biscuit and one butter biscuit side by side in a lab. People choose the butter version for taste and the shortening one for texture. We're all so complicated.

Top 15 butter Vs Shortening In Cookies - How to Make Perfect Recipes

Why This Debate Is Just Fun

Here's the thing. Biscuits are simple food. Flour, fat, liquid, heat. But change one tiny ingredient and you spark an entire argument. It's amazing.

This debate proves that even the most basic decisions in cooking can get passionate. Your grandma has a preference. Your neighbor has one too. Someone online has three blog posts about it.

And honestly? There's no wrong answer. Whether you team shortening or team butter, you're still making biscuits. You're still winning at life.

So next time you're in the kitchen, grab whatever fat you love. Bake a batch. Make them tall, make them flaky, make them delicious. Then argue about it at the dinner table. That's the real tradition.